depo 25 bonus 25 bebas ip depo 25 bonus 25 bebas ip depo 25 bonus 25 bebas ip depo 10 bonus 15 slot bonus new member 100 rtp slot gacor hari ini daftar slot via dana situs judi bola resmi rtp slot live
SBOBET slot dana
https://777slot.tech21.com/products/slot777/ bittersweetbynajla.com slot777 slot depo 10k bonus new member slot777 slot depo 10k bonus new member bonus new member slot gacor rtp live nexus slot slot gacor bonus new member nexus slot joker123 bonus new member joker123 joker123 slot777 slot777 slot depo 10k slot depo 10k joker123 slot depo 10k slot depo 10k rtp slot slot depo 10k slot depo 10k nexus slot nexus slot nexus slot slot online https://sman20surabaya.com/slot-garansi/ https://sman20surabaya.com/nexus-slot/ https://mak-techno.com/slot-garansi-kekalahan/ https://mak-techno.com/joker123/ https://jtdigitally.com/slot-garansi/ https://jtdigitally.com/slot-depo-10k/ https://ramones-project.eu/slot-garansi-kekalahan/ https://ramones-project.eu/joker123/ slot garansi kekalahan 100 slot minimal depo 10k slot minimal depo 10k slot garansi kekalahan 100 judi bola slot gacor 777 baksokemon.com riveroftimemuseum.org jedsoncampus.com salamsehat.com trackscales.com outbackadventuresdr.com gebzeninbaskani.com bandungindahgolf.com metalldetektortests.com sutherlandrealestate.com slot777 gacor https://live-on.levainbakery.com/products/rtp-slot-gacor-hari-ini/ http://rajathor.levainbakery.com/products/slot777 https://slot777-rajazeus.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gacor https://seo-slot777.levainbakery.com/products/daftar-slot777-tips-menang slot gacor joker123 online https://cuan-cuan.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gampang-cuan/ https://kiw-kiw.ahlemeyewear.com/products/situs-slot777-gacor/ https://hujan-duit.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://sikat.terus.dapperday.com/products/slot777-gacor/ http://slot.777.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://gacordunk.lilys.com/products/slot777-terpercaya/ SLOT777 TERBARU joker123 online slot777 online http://kejarchallenge.lilys.com/products/slot777-terbaru/ https://rangking-dong.lilys.com/products/slot777-online/ https://hariono.levainbakery.com/products/slot-joker123/ https://bangmessi.lilys.com/products/bocoran-rtpslot https://ronaldorank1.lilys.com/products/slot777 https://rankingdong.levainbakery.com/products/joker123 https://gacorabis.thebotanist.com/products/slot-gacor-gampang-menang/ https://anakgacor.lilys.com/products/slot-online/ https://tokopedia.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ https://gimicklu21.levainbakery.com/products/joker123-slot-terpopuler/ https://udinpetot.lilys.com/products/situs-slot-gacor-2023/ https://tukiyem-rtp.matthewwilliamson.com/products/bocoran-rtp-slot-gacor/ https://kores-banget.levainbakery.com/products/sbobet/ https://orang-dalam.matthewwilliamson.com/products/rtp-slot/ https://simonteli.kidrock.com/products/slot777-online/ https://mahpud-md.kidrock.com/products/slot777-gacor-hari-ini/ https://gedang-klutuk.levainbakery.com/products/slot-bonus-new-member-100/ https://dana-darurat.matthewwilliamson.com/products/situs-joker123/ https://slot-paijo.lilys.com/products/slot777/ https://lomba-rangking.lilys.com/products/nexus-slot/ https://gacorbosku.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://suhudilawan.lilys.com/products/link-slot777/ https://wkwkwk.thebotanist.com/products/slot777/ https://slot777dajal.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gacor/ http://cucugacor.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ https://jancokkk.thebotanist.com/products/slot-online-gacor/ https://tantegacor.levainbakery.com/products/slot-gacor/ http://sinchan.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ http://aminkan.thebotanist.com/products/link-slot-online/ https://mamakgacor.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-online/ https://lionel.tilley.com/products/rajazeus-situs-slot777 slot nexus login joker123 https://slot777.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/situs-slot777/ https://rtp-slot.baksokemon.com/products/rtp-live/ https://link-slot777.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slot777 https://slot-gacor.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slot-gacor https://baksobabi.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-gacor https://gacordunk.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-online https://slotonline.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slotonline-situs-slot/ https://slot777.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-situs-slot/ https://sbobet.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/sbobet/ https://rtp-slot.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/rtp-live-online-resmi/ https://rtp-slot.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/rtp-live-online-resmi/

Clipping – Conjur – Menor deficiente sob guarda pode receber pensão vitalícia por morte do avô, diz STJ

O menor portador de necessidades especiais que esteja sob guarda e tenha dependência econômica comprovada no momento do falecimento do guardião tem direito a pensão previdenciária vitalícia.

Com esse entendimento e por unanimidade, a Corte Especial do Superior Tribunal de Justiça deu provimento aos embargos de divergência ajuizados pelos representantes de um homem, portador de deficiência física e psíquica, pelo recebimento de pensão pelo falecimento do avô.

Quando a morte ocorreu, em 2000, o beneficiário ainda era menor de idade e já contava com apoio financeiro do avô, devido às necessidades especiais decorrentes de rubéola congênita. As instâncias ordinárias permitiram o pensionamento, mas o STJ reformou a decisão em 2009.

À época, a matéria previdenciária ainda era de competência da 3ª Seção, que tinha o entendimento pacífico segundo o qual a Medida Provisória 1.523/1996, convertida na Lei 9.528/1997, excluiu o menor sob guarda da relação de dependentes. Logo, a pensão seria incabível.

Em 2014, o STJ iniciou a virada jurisprudencial pelo julgamento do RMS 36.034, com a matéria já sob a competência da 1ª Seção. A pensão a menor sob guarda passou a ser admitida, pois interpretada a partir do Estatuto da Criança e do Adolescente e o princípio da dignidade humana. Em 2018, a corte fixou tese nesse sentido, em recursos repetitivos no REsp 1.411.258.

Essa evolução jurisprudencial levou o ministro Raul Araújo a estender a interpretação ao caso do menor que, além de dependente do avô, é também portador de necessidades especiais.

“A hipótese dos autos possui uma peculiaridade que torna a questão ainda mais sensível. São aplicáveis, além dos direitos previstos na Constituição, os do ECA e também do Estatuto da Pessoa com Deficiência. A pensão por morte é devida desde a data do óbito e de forma vitalícia, já que a deficiência é de longo prazo”, concluiu.

Admissibilidade por RMS

No mérito, a votação foi unânime. A Corte Especial divergiu quanto à admissibilidade dos embargos de divergência. Isso porque eles foram ajuizados tendo como acórdão paradigma o recurso em mandado de segurança da 1ª Seção. E RMS, conforme a jurisprudência do STJ, não é apto a comprovar dissídio jurisprudêncial.

Quando a parte impetrou os embargos de divergência, em 2015, o RMS era o único precedente do STJ sobre a matéria. Posteriormente, em 2017, incluiu outros dois julgados recentes como paradigma. “Isso é um problema”, destacou a ministra Maria Thereza de Assis Moura, ao abrir a divergência pelo não conhecimento dos embargos.

Ela também destacou que suplantar o problema de admissibilidade significaria rejulgar um caso que chegou ao STJ 2008 e para o qual foi aplicada a jurisprudência da época, como em tantos outros. Quanto à admissibilidade, foi seguida pelo ministro Herman Benjamin na divergência.

O ministro Raul preferiu suplantar o problema. “Penso que temos que mitigar aquilo que o tribunal entendeu e consagrou, mas que não pode, em matéria regimental, ser superior à Constituição, ao entendimento legal, àquilo que é próprio do juiz. Temos que, aqui e ali, em face ao regimento e a certos instrumentos normativos, ceder”, concordou o ministro Og Fernandes.

“A mudança da jurisprudência que se deu no RMS é quase que suficiente para conhecermos do recurso”, apontou a ministra Nancy Andrighi. “Existe a rescisória. Mas nós vamos impor mais esse calvário se já temos argumentos e podemos lavrar um acórdão que torne esclarecido que se trata de uma situação excepcionalíssima? Eu penso que não”, complementou.

EREsp 1.104.494

Fonte: Conjur

https://777slot.tech21.com/products/slot777/ bittersweetbynajla.com slot777 slot depo 10k bonus new member slot777 slot depo 10k bonus new member bonus new member slot gacor rtp live nexus slot slot gacor bonus new member nexus slot joker123 bonus new member joker123 joker123 slot777 slot777 slot depo 10k slot depo 10k joker123 slot depo 10k slot depo 10k rtp slot slot depo 10k slot depo 10k nexus slot nexus slot nexus slot slot online https://sman20surabaya.com/slot-garansi/ https://sman20surabaya.com/nexus-slot/ https://mak-techno.com/slot-garansi-kekalahan/ https://mak-techno.com/joker123/ https://jtdigitally.com/slot-garansi/ https://jtdigitally.com/slot-depo-10k/ https://ramones-project.eu/slot-garansi-kekalahan/ https://ramones-project.eu/joker123/ slot garansi kekalahan 100 slot minimal depo 10k slot minimal depo 10k slot garansi kekalahan 100 judi bola slot gacor 777 baksokemon.com riveroftimemuseum.org jedsoncampus.com salamsehat.com trackscales.com outbackadventuresdr.com gebzeninbaskani.com bandungindahgolf.com metalldetektortests.com sutherlandrealestate.com slot777 gacor https://live-on.levainbakery.com/products/rtp-slot-gacor-hari-ini/ http://rajathor.levainbakery.com/products/slot777 https://slot777-rajazeus.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gacor https://seo-slot777.levainbakery.com/products/daftar-slot777-tips-menang slot gacor joker123 online https://cuan-cuan.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gampang-cuan/ https://kiw-kiw.ahlemeyewear.com/products/situs-slot777-gacor/ https://hujan-duit.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://sikat.terus.dapperday.com/products/slot777-gacor/ http://slot.777.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://gacordunk.lilys.com/products/slot777-terpercaya/ SLOT777 TERBARU joker123 online slot777 online http://kejarchallenge.lilys.com/products/slot777-terbaru/ https://rangking-dong.lilys.com/products/slot777-online/ https://hariono.levainbakery.com/products/slot-joker123/ https://bangmessi.lilys.com/products/bocoran-rtpslot https://ronaldorank1.lilys.com/products/slot777 https://rankingdong.levainbakery.com/products/joker123 https://gacorabis.thebotanist.com/products/slot-gacor-gampang-menang/ https://anakgacor.lilys.com/products/slot-online/ https://tokopedia.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ https://gimicklu21.levainbakery.com/products/joker123-slot-terpopuler/ https://udinpetot.lilys.com/products/situs-slot-gacor-2023/ https://tukiyem-rtp.matthewwilliamson.com/products/bocoran-rtp-slot-gacor/ https://kores-banget.levainbakery.com/products/sbobet/ https://orang-dalam.matthewwilliamson.com/products/rtp-slot/ https://simonteli.kidrock.com/products/slot777-online/ https://mahpud-md.kidrock.com/products/slot777-gacor-hari-ini/ https://gedang-klutuk.levainbakery.com/products/slot-bonus-new-member-100/ https://dana-darurat.matthewwilliamson.com/products/situs-joker123/ https://slot-paijo.lilys.com/products/slot777/ https://lomba-rangking.lilys.com/products/nexus-slot/ https://gacorbosku.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://suhudilawan.lilys.com/products/link-slot777/ https://wkwkwk.thebotanist.com/products/slot777/ https://slot777dajal.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gacor/ http://cucugacor.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ https://jancokkk.thebotanist.com/products/slot-online-gacor/ https://tantegacor.levainbakery.com/products/slot-gacor/ http://sinchan.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ http://aminkan.thebotanist.com/products/link-slot-online/ https://mamakgacor.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-online/ https://lionel.tilley.com/products/rajazeus-situs-slot777 slot nexus login joker123 https://slot777.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/situs-slot777/ https://rtp-slot.baksokemon.com/products/rtp-live/ https://link-slot777.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slot777 https://slot-gacor.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slot-gacor https://baksobabi.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-gacor https://gacordunk.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-online https://slotonline.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slotonline-situs-slot/ https://slot777.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-situs-slot/ https://sbobet.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/sbobet/ https://rtp-slot.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/rtp-live-online-resmi/ https://rtp-slot.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/rtp-live-online-resmi/
https://777slot.tech21.com/products/slot777/ bittersweetbynajla.com slot777 slot depo 10k bonus new member slot777 slot depo 10k bonus new member bonus new member slot gacor rtp live nexus slot slot gacor bonus new member nexus slot joker123 bonus new member joker123 joker123 slot777 slot777 slot depo 10k slot depo 10k joker123 slot depo 10k slot depo 10k rtp slot slot depo 10k slot depo 10k nexus slot nexus slot nexus slot slot online https://sman20surabaya.com/slot-garansi/ https://sman20surabaya.com/nexus-slot/ https://mak-techno.com/slot-garansi-kekalahan/ https://mak-techno.com/joker123/ https://jtdigitally.com/slot-garansi/ https://jtdigitally.com/slot-depo-10k/ https://ramones-project.eu/slot-garansi-kekalahan/ https://ramones-project.eu/joker123/ slot garansi kekalahan 100 slot minimal depo 10k slot minimal depo 10k slot garansi kekalahan 100 judi bola slot gacor 777 baksokemon.com riveroftimemuseum.org jedsoncampus.com salamsehat.com trackscales.com outbackadventuresdr.com gebzeninbaskani.com bandungindahgolf.com metalldetektortests.com sutherlandrealestate.com slot777 gacor https://live-on.levainbakery.com/products/rtp-slot-gacor-hari-ini/ http://rajathor.levainbakery.com/products/slot777 https://slot777-rajazeus.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gacor https://seo-slot777.levainbakery.com/products/daftar-slot777-tips-menang slot gacor joker123 online https://cuan-cuan.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gampang-cuan/ https://kiw-kiw.ahlemeyewear.com/products/situs-slot777-gacor/ https://hujan-duit.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://sikat.terus.dapperday.com/products/slot777-gacor/ http://slot.777.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://gacordunk.lilys.com/products/slot777-terpercaya/ SLOT777 TERBARU joker123 online slot777 online http://kejarchallenge.lilys.com/products/slot777-terbaru/ https://rangking-dong.lilys.com/products/slot777-online/ https://hariono.levainbakery.com/products/slot-joker123/ https://bangmessi.lilys.com/products/bocoran-rtpslot https://ronaldorank1.lilys.com/products/slot777 https://rankingdong.levainbakery.com/products/joker123 https://gacorabis.thebotanist.com/products/slot-gacor-gampang-menang/ https://anakgacor.lilys.com/products/slot-online/ https://tokopedia.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ https://gimicklu21.levainbakery.com/products/joker123-slot-terpopuler/ https://udinpetot.lilys.com/products/situs-slot-gacor-2023/ https://tukiyem-rtp.matthewwilliamson.com/products/bocoran-rtp-slot-gacor/ https://kores-banget.levainbakery.com/products/sbobet/ https://orang-dalam.matthewwilliamson.com/products/rtp-slot/ https://simonteli.kidrock.com/products/slot777-online/ https://mahpud-md.kidrock.com/products/slot777-gacor-hari-ini/ https://gedang-klutuk.levainbakery.com/products/slot-bonus-new-member-100/ https://dana-darurat.matthewwilliamson.com/products/situs-joker123/ https://slot-paijo.lilys.com/products/slot777/ https://lomba-rangking.lilys.com/products/nexus-slot/ https://gacorbosku.levainbakery.com/products/slot777/ https://suhudilawan.lilys.com/products/link-slot777/ https://wkwkwk.thebotanist.com/products/slot777/ https://slot777dajal.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-gacor/ http://cucugacor.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ https://jancokkk.thebotanist.com/products/slot-online-gacor/ https://tantegacor.levainbakery.com/products/slot-gacor/ http://sinchan.lilys.com/products/slot-gacor/ http://aminkan.thebotanist.com/products/link-slot-online/ https://mamakgacor.levainbakery.com/products/slot777-online/ https://lionel.tilley.com/products/rajazeus-situs-slot777 slot nexus login joker123 https://slot777.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/situs-slot777/ https://rtp-slot.baksokemon.com/products/rtp-live/ https://link-slot777.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slot777 https://slot-gacor.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slot-gacor https://baksobabi.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-gacor https://gacordunk.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-online https://slotonline.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/slotonline-situs-slot/ https://slot777.baksokemon.com/products/slot777-situs-slot/ https://sbobet.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/sbobet/ https://rtp-slot.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/rtp-live-online-resmi/ https://rtp-slot.ahandfulofleaves.org/products/rtp-live-online-resmi/